大家好
我想請問用wpa_supplicant建立wifi p2p連線的問題
[問題]
我用筆電雙系統的win7配合intel的wifi p2p軟體，
我可以用手機的wifi direct搜尋到NB。
但是當我使用Linux時，在wpa_cli中打p2p_find [timeout]，
會直接跳出FAIL。我啟動wpa_supplicant的debug mode (wpa_supplicant ... -dt)，
在wpa_cli出現FAIL時並沒有跳出錯誤或警告訊息
想請教諸位前輩這種狀況我應該朝那邊走？
我不清楚問題點到底是在driver不支援還是wpa_supplicant設定有問題，
還是在其他地方...Orz
[網路資訊]
有人說 $ iw list吐出來的訊息中，
supported interface mode沒有P2P_GO & P2P_client就是設備不支援
=> 不過win7的環境可以用p2p搜尋
=> 另外想請教，iw list是顯示wifi chip的資訊還是driver看到的資訊？
iwlwifi-1000 (intel wireless driver)本身不支援P2P
Linux wireless上提到的
=> P2P我以為可以靠更上層的軟體解決，還是這driver不支援就沒辦法？
wpa_supplicant的README本身並沒有提到這點，他只有說:
Linux drivers that support cfg80211/nl80211. Even though there are
number of driver specific interface included in wpa_supplicant, please
note that Linux drivers are moving to use generic wireless configuration
interface driver_nl80211 (-Dnl80211 on wpa_supplicant command line)
should be the default option to start with before falling back to driver
specific interface.
Linux drivers that support WPA/WPA2 configuration with the generic
Linux wireless extensions (WE-18 or newer). Obsoleted by nl80211.
In theory, any driver that supports Linux wireless extensions can be
used with IEEE 802.1X (i.e., not WPA) when using ap_scan=0 option in
configuration file.
我自己是比較偏向wpa_supplicant的設定是不是有問題, 設定檔如下(.config)
http://paste.ideaslabs.com/show/3SHxXWBuJK
runtime config:
http://paste.ideaslabs.com/show/3GzWKUcbWR
[環境]
硬體環境為thinkpad T410 (Intel Centrino wireless-N 1000)
OS: Debian 7
libnl-3
libnl-3-dev
wpa_supplicant v2.4
wpa_cli v2.4
iwlwifi-1000 39.31.5.1 (intel driver)
--
$ iw list
...
Supported interface modes:
* IBSS
* managed
* monitor
software interface modes (can always be added):
* monitor
Supported TX frame types:
* P2P-client: 0x00 0x10 0x20 ...
* P2P-GO: 0x00 0x10 0x20 ...
Supported RX frame types:
* P2P-client: 0x40 0xd0
* P2P-GO: 0x00 0x20 0x40 0xa0 0xb0...
--
我想請問用wpa_supplicant建立wifi p2p連線的問題
[問題]
我用筆電雙系統的win7配合intel的wifi p2p軟體，
我可以用手機的wifi direct搜尋到NB。
但是當我使用Linux時，在wpa_cli中打p2p_find [timeout]，
會直接跳出FAIL。我啟動wpa_supplicant的debug mode (wpa_supplicant ... -dt)，
在wpa_cli出現FAIL時並沒有跳出錯誤或警告訊息
想請教諸位前輩這種狀況我應該朝那邊走？
我不清楚問題點到底是在driver不支援還是wpa_supplicant設定有問題，
還是在其他地方...Orz
[網路資訊]
有人說 $ iw list吐出來的訊息中，
supported interface mode沒有P2P_GO & P2P_client就是設備不支援
=> 不過win7的環境可以用p2p搜尋
=> 另外想請教，iw list是顯示wifi chip的資訊還是driver看到的資訊？
iwlwifi-1000 (intel wireless driver)本身不支援P2P
Linux wireless上提到的
=> P2P我以為可以靠更上層的軟體解決，還是這driver不支援就沒辦法？
wpa_supplicant的README本身並沒有提到這點，他只有說:
Linux drivers that support cfg80211/nl80211. Even though there are
number of driver specific interface included in wpa_supplicant, please
note that Linux drivers are moving to use generic wireless configuration
interface driver_nl80211 (-Dnl80211 on wpa_supplicant command line)
should be the default option to start with before falling back to driver
specific interface.
Linux drivers that support WPA/WPA2 configuration with the generic
Linux wireless extensions (WE-18 or newer). Obsoleted by nl80211.
In theory, any driver that supports Linux wireless extensions can be
used with IEEE 802.1X (i.e., not WPA) when using ap_scan=0 option in
configuration file.
我自己是比較偏向wpa_supplicant的設定是不是有問題, 設定檔如下(.config)
http://paste.ideaslabs.com/show/3SHxXWBuJK
runtime config:
http://paste.ideaslabs.com/show/3GzWKUcbWR
[環境]
硬體環境為thinkpad T410 (Intel Centrino wireless-N 1000)
OS: Debian 7
libnl-3
libnl-3-dev
wpa_supplicant v2.4
wpa_cli v2.4
iwlwifi-1000 39.31.5.1 (intel driver)
--
$ iw list
...
Supported interface modes:
* IBSS
* managed
* monitor
software interface modes (can always be added):
* monitor
Supported TX frame types:
* P2P-client: 0x00 0x10 0x20 ...
* P2P-GO: 0x00 0x10 0x20 ...
Supported RX frame types:
* P2P-client: 0x40 0xd0
* P2P-GO: 0x00 0x20 0x40 0xa0 0xb0...
--
All Comments